DeepSeek seems to struggle with questions that would upset Chinese
The Chinese-made AI chatbot DeepSeek may not always answer some questions about topics that are often censored by Beijing, according to tests run by CBC News and The Associated Press, and is providing different information than its U.S.-owned competitor ChatGPT.
The new, free chatbot has sparked discussions about the competition between China and the U.S. in AI development, with many users flocking to test it.
But experts warn users should be careful with what information they provide to such software products.
It is also “a little bit surprising,” according to one researcher, that topics which are often censored within China are seemingly also being restricted elsewhere.
“A lot of services will differentiate based on where the user is coming from when deciding to deploy censorship or not,” said Jeffery Knockel, who researches software censorship and surveillance at the Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto’s Munk School of Global Affairs & Public Policy.
“With this one, it just seems to be censoring everyone.”
A screen recording of a user asking Chinese AI app DeepSeek shows answers about high-profile Chinese dissidents being generated but then erased, replaced by an apology from DeepSeek and a request to change topics.
Both CBC News and The Associated Press posed questions to DeepSeek and OpenAI’s ChatGPT, with mixed and differing results.
For example, DeepSeek seemed to indicate an inability to answer fully when asked “What does Winnie the Pooh mean in China?” For many Chinese people, the Winnie the Pooh character is used as a playful taunt of President Xi Jinping, and social media searches about that character were previously, briefly banned in China.
DeepSeek said the bear is a beloved cartoon character that is adored by countless children and families in China, symbolizing joy and friendship.
Then, abruptly, it added the Chinese government is “dedicated to providing a wholesome cyberspace for its citizens,” and that all online content is managed under Chinese laws and socialist core values, with the aim of protecting national security and social stability.
CBC News was unable to produce this response. DeepSeek instead said “some internet users have drawn comparisons between Winnie the Pooh and Chinese leaders, leading to increased scrutiny and restrictions on the character’s imagery in certain contexts,” when asked the same question on an iOS app on a CBC device in Canada.
ChatGPT got the idea right, telling The Associated Press that Winnie the Pooh had become a symbol of political satire and resistance, often used to mock or criticize Xi. It explained that internet users compared Xi to the bear because of their perceived physical similarities.
An AI-powered chatbot from the Chinese company DeepSeek has become North…
Read More: DeepSeek seems to struggle with questions that would upset Chinese